These questions are from a recent Q&A with the fantastic pre-med society at BYU-Idaho. We wanted to be sure to give each question its due attention for their benefit and for any others with similar questions.
What was the hardest part of medical school in first, second, third, and fourth years?
Any answer I give will lack the external validity required to be generalized to every school and every individual.
For example, my school organized my 3rd and 4th year rotations and provided housing or a housing stipend if I had to rotate outside my home base city. I know of schools that do none of those things and basically say “good luck” and make you figure out your own clinical rotations and are still happy to charge you $50K+ a year for tuition. That would’ve been pretty hard.
For simplicity’s sake, and for the sake of actually providing you with useful advice, let us focus on what is expected of you as a learner, and not what is required of you to navigate the broken, inefficient, and borderline extortionate world of medical education.
MS1 (First Year)
Picture this, you walk into orientation on day one. All your new classmates are slowly filtering in and taking a seat. You feel deep within your bowels that you are experiencing the start of something significant, and it kind of makes you sick. You are nervous to talk to people because you think someone might discover that you’re actually too dumb to be there and that the admissions committee made a mistake. This feeling is further exacerbated as you go around the room and learn about all the interesting people in your cohort and all the great things they’ve done. You think “Oh crap, what have I done? What if I can’t do this?” You’ve just had your first brush with imposter syndrome, my friend. And this likely won’t be the last.
Imposter syndrome is the first foe to vanquish in first year. You get there little by little as you get accustomed to the pace and style of instruction in your classes. The proverbial “firehose” opens up and you feel overwhelmed until you realize that you’re actually learning the same information you’ve seen before, just presented more quickly and more focused on human physiology and its intersection with disease.
The hardest part of MS1 is settling into a rhythm of sustainable studying that translates into acceptable scores. You will experiment with a couple different methods, it will feel uncomfortable, but eventually you will find the winning combination. Here’s a hint, the answer is found in some combination of a decent study group, incorporating outside review materials, and making sure you’re retaining information (Anki).
You have already had academic success. Now you’re going to distill that during MS1 and level up your efficiency. The hardest part of MS1? Finding your confidence and learning how to learn quickly.
MS2 (Second Year)
Feels a lot like MS1, only now you’ve got a solid foundation to build on. It’s time you start looking ahead to Step 1, which looms less ominously over your shoulder because it is pass/fail but remains a beast of a test. You also start feeling the pressure to squeeze in some research and extracurricular type of activities into your routine. You don’t know for sure what you want to do, but you want to be competitive no matter what. The little free time you have quickly dries up as you add in Step 1 review and specialty shadowing/leadership activities.
You start to get annoyed with your instructors when they cover material you think represents minutia because you’re certain you could cover more ground on your own with your library of review materials.
You experience the growing pains associated with taking what you’ve learned so far in medicine and applying it to standardized patient experiences (and hopefully real patient experiences). It’s awkward and sweaty, like a middle school date.
You’ve got a lot to do. You’ve got a big test to pass. You may feel more stressed than you did in first year and little things about your program that you were happy to overlook during MS1 are starting to make your eye twitch.
The hardest part of MS2 is keeping your cool and being nice to those around you while you struggle to juggle coursework, study for (and pass) Step 1, and learn how to be a clinician so you don’t look like a total shmuck on your third-year rotations.
MS3 (Third Year)
If your school follows the traditional format, the MS3 year will be….unique. If you ask me, which you did, I’d tell you it’s the absolute worst. You just get thrown into clinical rotations with very little preparation. Even though you had some pretend rounds and patient interviews during MS2, nothing truly prepares you for what’s next. It’s shocking and surreal. You look around for cameras because you’re sure you’re being “punked”.
Then you find out that now you are actually getting graded, and that the majority of your clinical grade comes from subject assessment of somebody you might work with once or twice in a 6-12 week period. You take a test as well, but it really only accounts for 10-20% of your final grade. Oh, and there’s no dedicated time to study for this test.
After you take Step 1, you feel like you have all the answers. But on the wards, you realize you’ve essentially been studying “theoretical medicine” up until this point. Real medicine is much less clear cut, and frankly, unsatisfying. Once in a while you get a classic presentation of something, and you absolutely smoke the pimping questions from your attending. That restores your confidence…a little.
If you hated the first two years of medical school, you will probably really enjoy the last two. I loved the first two, didn’t care too much for the last two.
You are getting a taste of what life will really be like as a doctor. You will work long hours and work weekends. You will have to keep up your studying habits because the NBME and USMLE decided the fate of your future rests with your performance on Step 2 rather than Step 1.
Little by little you get your routine figured out. After your first couple rotations you understand your role on the team. You get to scrub into surgeries, take care of your own patients, make real medical decisions, and do all the things you’ve always dreamed. Pretty soon, you realize you are having a lot of fun. You meet interesting people and get exposed to a bunch of different specialties. You learn what you are interested in and what you need to stay far away from.
The hardest part of MS3 is the stress of the first 2-3 months of rotations while you figure out what the crap you are supposed to do, and how to do it.
MS4 (Fourth year)
Ah, fourth year. The apology for third year.
You actually know what you’re doing. You now get to rotate through specialties that you are interested in while you solidify your choice of residency. You still have stress because you have to study for and take Step 2, but Step 2 is testing more of the common day-to-day knowledge that you already know pretty well from rotations.
You take electives that you know will have a light schedule so you can build up some more volunteer experiences and start working on residency application stuff. You start researching residencies and meeting with specialty advisors to figure out how to put together your application. Maybe you plan out a few “away” rotations at institutions you are interested in. These are more intense, but at least you’re doing what you’re interested in.
The first half of MS4 is full of hard work and planning, but the second half is very light as you start interviewing for residency. The Match is an exciting and stressful time, but it’s a lot of fun.
The hardest part of MS4 is finishing your required rotations strong, filling out your ERAS application, and dealing with the anxiety of awaiting The Match results.